Was checking out the newly unblocked news.bbc.co.uk the other day and came across the Question Time Shanghai Edition page.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/question_time/4338447.stm
It's hard to believe that the show was three years ago. It still seems very fresh. We were shooting a promo piece for the Howard Johnson hotel at the time when had a call from David Wivell, now a good friend, who wondered if we would be interested in helping coordinate the programme.
We met the BBC's rep on the programme (which is actually made by a company called Mentorn, based in Oxford) in Shanghai a few days later and a month or so after that we went behind the scenes for a live Question Time from Cambridge.
David Dimbleby was an gentleman, as kindly and wise backstage as he is stern and fair on air. And the rest of the QT team turned out to be very warm and welcoming. One of the highlights was the after show dinner at the Riverside Restaurant in Cambridge. LT and I sat next to David Coleman, the director, and had an absolute riot. The guests from the show (Armando Ianucci, John Redwood, Caroline Lucas, Lord Falconer and Anne Leslie) joined us and David D was a wonderful host, making the rounds with the wine to keep us all topped up.
But for all the good will and experience, it was hard to believe then that we would manage to bring a live political debate show to China. And even if we managed it, many people believed that we would be tied down with restrictions on what could be debated, and lumbered with a government-picked audience.
Months of negotiations and hard work followed on the China end (especially from David W), and eventually paid off. To the amazement of much of the Western press, we were promised a unrestricted show. There were no limits on the topics that could be discussed and the audience was to be hand picked by the QT team based on their usual requirement for balance of views and demographics (the only restriction on members being that they all had to speak English).
The process was not without its hiccups. Visas for the UK team were very slow to come through and it wasn't clear they would make it until about a week before the show. And then they did come through, so it was all fine.
The last blip was the issue of the audience. We (LT and I were listed as producers by this point) had invited applications from as many organizations as we had contacts with, as well as the general public. We received about 400 or so and called most of them to check their English and to see what sort of issues they wanted to talk about. And then, a couple of weeks before the show, we were contacted by the Shanghai foreign affairs office to see if we needed any help finding audience. We mentioned that we were weak on academics - people who might have knowledge about and informed opinions on social issues. They sent us a list of about 5o or so scholars and we vetted them the same way we had for the rest of the list, checking their English and making sure that there was a good spread of opinions.
A day or two before filming, the English press got wind of the story and started reporting that we had been forced to include government stooges in the audience. It blew over very quickly but it was a lesson in sensationalism. Out of a total audience of around 150, we had in fact taken something like 25 from the FOA list. It was a small number, and they had all been through the same process as the rest of the audience. The QT team was amused more than anything. In fact, they told us, it was quite common for them to get lists of potential audience members from local government offices in the UK.
The show on March 10 went well. Panelists included Chris Patten, David Tang, Isabel Hilton, government spokesman Liu Jianchao and WTO negotiator Long Yongtu. Questions were picked from suggestions made by the audience in the hour before the show (as they always are) and not checked by anyone outside the show production team. Topics included Taiwan, human rights, and democracy in Hong Kong. The panelists' debate was lively. The audience proved to be subtle and open to debate too. Opinions differed wildly.
After they show, the production team and most of the panelists headed off for the ritual buffet dinner and drinks. There was a buzz in the air and everyone felt they had taken part in a remarkable event. It was the first of its kind in China and proved to us that despite the obvious restrictions a lot can be achieved here.
The web page I found today took me right back to March, 2005. If you have a moment, please read down the comments at the bottom of the page - reactions to the show. They are telling.